| |
I. INTRODUCTION
Medi-Cal The Santa Barbara
Regional Health Authority (SBRHA or "the Authority") administers
several publicly-funded health care plans serving the residents
of Santa Barbara County. Its primary plan, the Santa Barbara
Health Initiative (SBHI), began operations September 1, 1983.
The potential advantages of such a locally-administered plan for
publicly-funded health insurance - compared to the inefficient
and unresponsive State-run Medi-Cal program -- were advanced by
Dr. Lawrence Hart, at that time the Health Officer and Director
of the Santa Barbara County Department of Health Services. It
was Dr. Hart's unrelenting efforts in working with community
leaders and health professionals that ensured such a plan would
become a reality. Under its State enabling legislation (Health &
Safety Code Sec. 101675 et. seq.), the Authority assumed
responsibility for the Medi-Cal program in Santa Barbara County.
The program is now acknowledged to be the oldest Medicaid
managed care program of its kind in the country. The Authority
has proven that the Medi-Cal program can be operated more
equitably and efficiently on a county level, with greater
participation of private and public physicians and other health
providers. The Authority has been able to organize the Medi-Cal
delivery system of health care in the County in an innovative
way due to the Health Care Financing Administration (HCFA)
granting the Authority waivers from specific provisions of
federal Medicaid law. Under these waivers, the Authority is
categorized as a "Health Insuring Organization" (HIO). These
waivers are renewed every two years, allowing HCFA to evaluate
the operations and effectiveness of the program. The SBHI
program initially received pilot project status from the State
and Federal governments to test primary care physician case
management, to contain costs through a budgeted health system,
and to offer provider and member incentives. SBHI has since
become a demonstration program for other counties and states,
and has served as a model for Medicaid reform.
Access for Infants and Mothers (AIM)
The Authority also maintains an exclusive contract with the
State of California to administer the Access for Infants and
Mothers program in Santa Barbara County -- a program that
provides medical services to women during their pregnancy and to
their children for the first two years of life. The AIM program
is designed for those who do not have health insurance but do
not qualify for Medi-Cal, and is paid for through State tobacco
taxes and subscriber contributions. The Authority program is
called "Prenatal PLUS 2".
Healthy Families In addition,
the Authority is one of the participating health plans in
Santa Barbara County offering residents care for children
under the Healthy Families program -- California's version
of the Federal Children's Health Initiative. Again, this is
a program that provides medical coverage for those who do
not have health insurance but cannot qualify for the Medi-Cal program.
Top
II.
POWERS OF SBRHA UNDER STATE LAW
The Authority contracts with the State of California to
arrange for, but not directly provide, health care benefits
to the eligible program populations in Santa Barbara County,
in exchange for a per capita reimbursement (i.e. at-risk).
In turn, the Authority is empowered to contract for health
services and negotiate rates with providers, administer the
programs locally, process claims, and assure access to
covered services for eligible members and subscribers
residing in Santa Barbara County. For SBHI, Medi-Cal
eligibility is determined by the County Social Services
Department or by the Federal Social Security Administration,
according to State and Federal standards. Independent
contractors to the State determine eligibility under the AIM
and Healthy Families programs. The Authority is advised
monthly of eligible members via secure data lines.
The Authority is at-risk for arranging and paying for those
covered health care benefits that are not specifically
excluded under its contracts with the State. Annual revenues
from its contracts approximate $110 million. Certain
benefits under the Medi-Cal program are not covered through
SBHI, and remain available to members through the State
Fee-for-Service Medi-Cal program and include, but are not
limited to:
- dental services;
- Child Health & Disability Prevention (CHDP);
- Short-Doyle Mental Health Services (usually mental
health services offered through County health departments)
as well as other mental health services; and
- adult day health care.
Top
III. GOVERNANCE OF SBRHA
The Authority was formally established October 18,
1982, at which time it became independent of County
government in Santa Barbara. Essentially, the only
relationship with County government is that the County Board
of Supervisors appoints the Authority's 11-member Board. All
policy is set by the Board of Directors, which is composed
of health providers, government officials, and other
community and consumer representatives. The Board is
responsible for disbursement of all funds targeted to meet
the health care needs of an average of 55,000 eligibles
across the three programs in Santa Barbara County.
The Board is assisted in its efforts in governing the
program by various advisory committees. As a public entity,
the process of obtaining input from its constituents is one
of the central features of the Authority. This process
ensures open meeting debate on all issues of importance, and
guarantees that the agency is accountable to the communities
it serves. The committees' activities include, but are not
limited to: developing and implementing the Authority's
Quality Assessment and Improvement Plan, reviewing quality
of care concerns and corrective action plans, proposing
resolution for provider complaints, reviewing provider's
credentialing and recredentialing files and recommending to
the Board of Director's their participation in the network,
and reviewing and recommending to the Board of Directors
additions and deletions to the Authority's
Formulary.
Community Advisory Board (CAB)
On November 24, 1982, the Board established a community
advisory board ("CAB") to review and comment on proposed
policies and actions of the board dealing with the
arrangements for health care within the jurisdiction of the
authority. The CAB participates in establishing the public
policy of the Authority. The Board has approved the CAB
mission, goals and membership guidelines.
The CAB provides a forum for the Authority's members, their
representatives, and community agencies to discuss common
issues of interest and importance. In addition, the CAB
provides member input into the Authority's quality
improvement process. The committee has the following
functions:
- Review, on a quarterly basis, complaints received in the
field offices, and make recommendations for quality
improvement.
- Review, on a secondary appeal level, any non-medically
related grievances, making recommendations for resolution.
- Review and provide input regarding
Member Rights and
Responsibilities and various member communication materials.
- Make recommendations regarding Member Services Quality
Improvement Activities (e.g. Member Satisfaction Survey).
Top
IV. MORE ON SBRHA PROGRAM ELIGIBILITY
Medi-Cal Those individuals who
qualify for Medi-Cal and are residents of Santa Barbara
County are automatically inscribed into the SBHI
program - with a few minor exceptions. Unlike most Medicaid
managed care plans, SBRHA accepts the risk for the full Medi-Cal population, which include both cash assistance
eligibles and those eligible through the SSI program
(including the aged, blind, and disabled). SBHI membership
includes "crossover" (i.e., those persons with both Medi-Cal
and Medicare coverage). SBHI members are classified as
follows:
Class I Members are those case-managed by a Primary Care
Physician (PCP)
Special Class Members (approximately 10-15 percent of all
eligibles) are members who cannot realistically be
case-managed under a capitation model by PCPs, or are case
managed by another entity. These members include, but are
not limited to:
- those who are eligible on a retroactive basis;
- have cleared a share of cost obligation;
- reside in long-term care institutions;
- have a confirmed diagnosis of renal failure or AIDS;
- are receiving total parenteral nutrition or total
parenteral hyperalimentation for chronic conditions; or,
- are eligible for an organ transplant.
The State issues Medi-Cal members a
Benefits Identification
Card (BIC), which provides basic member information. In
addition, SBHI members receive a SBHI Identification card
which gives the member's PCP's name and telephone number.
Neither card alone serves as evidence of Medi-Cal
eligibility; providers must check on a monthly basis to
determine continued eligibility.
AIM On January 1, 1993, the
Authority entered into its first contract with the
California Managed Risk Medical Insurance Board (MRMIB)
as a
participating health plan to serve subscribers to the Access
for Infants and Mothers (AIM) program in Santa Barbara
County. The AIM program covers pregnant women who have no
health insurance for their pregnancy, who are not eligible
for Medi-Cal, and whose annual family income is between 200%
and 300% of the federal poverty level. These women are
covered during pregnancy and the first sixty days after
delivery. The infants born to these mothers are then covered
for the first two years of life. AIM subscribers pay a small
portion of the cost of coverage (2% of the total family
income), and the remainder is provided by MRMIB through
tobacco tax funds. Since 1995, SBRHA's has held an exclusive
contract with MRMIB for AIM subscribers. The Authority's
program is called "Prenatal PLUS 2".
Healthy Families In March,
1998, MRMIB awarded the Authority the "community provider"
designation in Santa Barbara County for the Healthy Families
program. The Authority was granted this status due to its
proven ability to contract with all of the designated
"safety net" providers in the County. This State and
federally subsidized program offers benefits to subscribers
ages one to 19 who are not eligible for no-cost Medi-Cal,
and do not have other health insurance coverage. Applicants
pay monthly premiums, in addition to co-payments for
specified services. Subscribers choosing the Authority's
program, known as "Healthy Families through the Santa
Barbara Regional Authority", pay lower premiums due to the
community provider designation.
Top
V. GOALS AND OBJECTIVES OF SBRHA
The goals of the Authority in all its programs are to:
- ensure access to quality care;
- maintain and increase physician participation;
- expedite payments to providers;
- increase SBHI provider reimbursement through fair
incentive programs based on utilization management and
quality of care criteria;
- improve the conditions fostering continuity of care;
- reduce unnecessary paperwork;
- establish more responsive program management through
local administration of the program; and
- contain program medical expenditures.
The Authority has a system for the review of the quality of
health care to identify, evaluate, and remedy problems
relating to access, continuity and quality of care, and
utilization. The Authority's Quality Assessment and
Improvement Program ("QAIP") provides a description of the
operation of the review system. The purpose of the QAIP is
to continuously improve the quality of care and services
provided by the Authority and its contracted provider
network.
Through its QAIP, the Authority continues to refine its
methods for assuring access to care for its members and
subscribers, to keep pace with current trends in the managed
care sector, to develop programs for improvement in disease
management; to focus on quality studies and measures, to
assure provider qualifications meet participation standards
through a credentialing program, and to emphasize SBHI
physician incentive rewards that are based on quality
measures as opposed to simple reduction of utilization. In
June 2000, the Authority was awarded a Knox-Keene Health
Care Service Plan license by the State Department of Managed
Health Care for its Healthy Families program, and in the
future plans to obtain National Committee on Quality
Assurance (NCQA) certification.
Top
VI. PROVIDER PARTICIPATION
The Authority works with all interested health care providers
in Santa Barbara County who are licensed, and/or are
certified by the State to provide Medi-Cal services. This is
central to the Authority's philosophy to be a
provider-inclusive program, rather than restricting members
to a small number of exclusive contractors. However, in
order to be paid, providers must execute a written contract
with the Authority. Primary care physicians (PCPs) and
specialists may contract with the Authority either
individually, in groups, or as outpatient clinic providers.
Formal groups of primary care and specialty physicians may
choose to contract with the Authority as a single
contracting entity. In addition, the Authority contracts
with out-of-county providers as needed to assure specialized
services to its members/subscribers.
Top
VII. CASE MANAGEMENT BY PRIMARY CARE PHYSICIANS (PCPs)
Primary Care Network The
central feature of the Authority's programs is the
utilization of a primary care network. Under this approach,
the majority of members/subscribers residing in the County
are required to choose a PCP, who then serves as a case
manager for the patient. Members/subscribers may choose a
general practitioner, family physician, pediatrician,
internist, or an obstetrician/gynecologist to coordinate
their care and provide referrals to specialty services. To
participate as a PCP for pediatric Medi-Cal, Healthy
Families, and AIM members/subscribers under 20 years of age
providers must additionally provide proof of valid Child
Health and Disability Prevention Program (CHDP)
certification. PCPs may take as few as 50 patients, or, for
large groups or clinics, up to a maximum of 2,000.
Case Management and Utilization
Management In order to ensure that
members/subscribers receive necessary care, utilization of
services are closely monitored and controlled by the PCP as
well as by the Authority. Generally, most health services
are coordinated by the PCP. With the exception of true
emergencies and a few other exceptions, all levels and types
of covered health services are rendered either by the PCP or
by other providers with the PCP's authorization. Normally,
the most common medical conditions can be treated by the
PCP. Specialty referrals, hospitalizations, lab, and X-ray
must be authorized, in a timely manner, by the PCP or by a
designated back-up physician. These authorizations, either
on Referral Authorization Forms (RAFs) or on Treatment
Authorization Requests (TARs), are required for
reimbursement by the Authority. SBHI is consistent with the
benefit limitations and restrictions applicable to the
Statewide Medi-Cal program, which include prior
authorization for TAR-designated procedures. This control
and authorization function is central to the "Case
Management" concept of primary care networks, and aids in
reduction of duplicative utilization or unnecessary
treatments, and ultimately in controlling costs.
The Authority's Information Technology (IT) Department
prepares monthly SBHI status reports for PCPs, which present
information on various utilization and quality measures.
Such reports permit the physician or group provider to
monitor performance and alter practice patterns as
necessary.
Top
VIII. PHYSICIAN and MEMBER/SUBSCRIBER RELATIONSHIP
Member Selection of Primary Care
Physicians (PCPs) Each member (in SBHI, Class I only)
and subscriber is given the opportunity to choose a PCP from
a list of available PCPs who will agree to act as his/her
case manager. It is important to stress that
members/subscribers have freedom of choice in selecting
their PCP. The member/subscriber is responsible for
contacting their PCP for all care, and the physician is
responsible for arranging needed care for the
member/subscriber.
Resolving Grievances The
Authority has established appeals and grievance procedures
which work to protect both members/subscribers and
providers. Should there be failure to establish a good
physician-patient relationship, members/subscribers and
providers may request that a change be made. Of course,
members/subscribers and providers may have other specific
reasons to file appeals or grievances, i.e. appeal of a TAR
decision or a complaint the provider feels is not
satisfactorily resolved.
Top
IX. FLOW OF FUNDS
The State's payment to the Authority is based on a monthly per
capita calculation. These rates are renegotiated annually.
The State pays to the Authority a sum each month based on
the number of eligible members in each program. For
Medi-Cal, the per capita rates are based on Medi-Cal aid
categories. It is important to note that the State also
limits the risk under the SBHI program to a maximum of
$75,000 of expenses per SBHI member per contract year. In
order to more fairly spread the risk of random high cost
illness over the entire Class I member population, and to
better protect both the Authority and the PCPs, there is
also a "catastrophic" risk limit for PCPs; the PCP Incentive
Pools are charged only up to the first $15,000 per member
per year.
Top
X. PROVIDER PAYMENT METHODS
Reimbursement to PCPs (For
Case-Managed Members/Subscribers) Each month, SBHI
PCPs are paid 80 percent of the primary care capitation,
based on the number of members, and their aid codes and
age/sex. This "guaranteed payment" is the physician's
"pre-paid" compensation for providing primary care services
and for accepting case management responsibilities. The
payment is made regardless of whether the SBHI members
assigned to the PCP actually use services that month. SBHI
PCPs also participate in an incentive payment system, which
is described later. PCPs for the Authority's other programs
are paid at that specific program's fee-for-service rate. In
addition, AIM Pediatric Case Managers receive a monthly case
management fee.
Reimbursement to Referral Physicians
(For All Members/Subscribers) Those specialty
(referral) physicians who have contracts with the Authority
have the choice of accepting or rejecting referrals made to
them by PCPs. Reimbursement for most specialists for SBHI is
based on prevailing or a percentage increase of Medi-Cal
fee-for-service rates, although some at-risk contracts or
special rates are used when needed to assure access. Rates
under the Authority's other programs are generally higher
than Medi-Cal rates. Specialty care rendered to case managed
members/subscribers requires written authorization from the
PCP for reimbursement by the Authority.
Reimbursement to Hospitals (For All
Members/Subscribers) Hospitals in the County
participate by signing contracts with the Authority; all
hospitals in the County are currently under contract with
SBHI. Prospective rates are negotiated as all-inclusive per
diem rates. These amounts combine routine and ancillary
costs in a single negotiated rate for each major
accommodation code. Payments are made to hospitals by the
Authority only for services rendered to eligible
members/subscribers which, other than true emergencies or
noted exceptions, are authorized by the PCP and/or the
Authority.
Reimbursement to Long-Term Care Institutions (For
all Members/Subscribers) Long term care facilities
are paid by the Authority as they are under the State
Medi-Cal program (i.e., on a flat rate per diem basis). The
Authority is one of the few Medi-Cal managed care plans in
California to fully cover long term care services.
Reimbursement to Pharmacies and
Other Providers (For All Members/Subscribers)
Pharmacies and other providers (ambulance, diagnostic
laboratories, etc.) are paid as they are under the State
Medi-Cal program, with generally higher rates under the AIM
and Healthy Families programs. Payment is made for drugs
covered under the State Formulary or that of the Authority,
which has expanded the coverage beyond what the State
allows.
Reimbursement to Providers of
Limited Services (For All SBHI Members) Certain
providers may render services to SBHI members without the
authorization of the primary care physician, subject to the
existing Medi-Cal service visit limitations. These providers
include chiropractors, acupuncturists, and certain
therapists.
(Note: Under SBHI, any provider can see a Special Class
member, and is paid at prevailing or a percentage increase
of Medi-Cal fee-for-service rates).
Top
XI. SBHI PCP INCENTIVE PROGRAM
Quality and Utilization
Performance-Based System PCP risk-sharing has been an
integral part of SBHI since the program's inception. The
risk-sharing program had historically been based upon the
PCP's prospects for shared surpluses generated only through
appropriate utilization management, and thus costs reduced
below budgeted levels. However, financial incentive payments
are now based upon both utilization and quality performance
measures for PCPs, relative to their peers who share the
same provider type (e.g. pediatrics, internal medicine,
etc.).
The program incorporates measures indicative of quality of
care designed to be consistent with Authority objectives,
such as measuring accessibility to care through PCP office
hours, evaluation of medical chart quality, and looking at
how many members are receiving appropriate preventive
services. Such quality measures are determined through a
process involving staff, and most importantly, participating
physician input, and are continually evolving to better
reflect overall quality as more quality measures are
incorporated.
Funding of the Incentive Program
The funds used for the SBHI incentive program are based upon
Authority's historical pay-outs under the previous incentive
methodology. Each pool is based upon a percentage of the
individual PCP's monthly guaranteed capitation rates for
Class l (or "case managed") members, as specified under the
PCP Agreement. The "Utilization Pool" is established from
the remaining twenty percent of the capitation that is not
paid monthly to the PCP (i.e., the PCP's withhold). The
remaining funds are contributed by the Authority, and are
equal to a percent of the PCP's guaranteed capitation during
the specified time period. These funds together equal the
total of the PCP's Utilization Pool. Funding for the
"Quality Pool" is contributed by the Authority and is equal
to a percent of the PCP's guaranteed capitation during the
specified time period.
For each PCP, the Utilization Pool is allocated into
sub-categories. This is accomplished by multiplying the
total dollar amount in the Pool by specific percentages,
which are an approximation of historical allocations to
these probable expense categories: physician/outpatient
hospital expenses, inpatient hospital expenses, and pharmacy
expenses.
For each PCP, the Quality Pool, which is reviewed and
evaluated annually, is allocated into sub-categories such as
encounters, emergency room visits, facility audits, office
hours, increased access, chart quality, etc. by multiplying
the total dollar amount in the Pool by specific percentages.
Supporting Reports and Payment
Schedule The PCP's Monthly Incentive summary report
is prepared monthly and mailed automatically to all active
PCPs. Other supplemental schedules reflect details from the
summary, and are available to the PCP upon request. In
addition to the guaranteed monthly capitation received by
all PCPs, eligible PCPs are paid Incentive Payments in two
installments following the close of the fiscal year (June
30). The initial pay-out of 25% of the estimated Total
Incentive Payment is made within two weeks after the close
of the fiscal year, with the balance of the final incentive
payment paid no later than the following December. Since
1983, contracting PCPs have received over $16 million in
SBHI incentive payments from the Authority.
Top
XII. CLAIMS PROCESSING/REPORTING OF SERVICES
The Authority performs in-house processing and adjudication of
claims and payment to providers for authorized services
rendered to its members. Staff is available to assist and
train provider staffs, answer questions, and resolve claim
and/or payment problems in a timely fashion. This
arrangement has been successful in assisting providers in
billing, simplifying submission procedures, and reducing the
time between claim submission and receipt of payment.
Accurate data submitted by providers on the claims forms
provides the basis of the Authority's reporting of Health
Plan Employer Data and Information Set (HEDIS) measures to
regulatory agencies requesting such data.
Primary care services rendered by a SBHI PCP are considered
to be "encounters", as such services are covered by the
monthly capitation payment. Such encounters are reported
once each month on claim forms or on special encounter
forms.
Top
XIII. INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY
The Authority has since its inception dedicated resources to
the development of a cutting edge information system -- one
that would encourage provider participation, and provide
health professionals and plan management with the ability to
monitor utilization and quality measures. The system also
permits electronic submission of claims (approximately 65%
of all claims are now submitted to the Authority in this
fashion). In addition, the Authority's IT Department has
developed a unique automated eligibility verification
system, called the "Provider Network System" (PNS). The PNS
permits providers in their offices to scan SBHI member ID
cards, and to immediately determine eligibility status, PCP
information, and other important data about the patient.
This system is being expanded to provide a mechanism for
full secure networking with providers, with functions to
include e-mail and on-line claims submission.
Top
XIV. CONCLUSION
Through many years of experience, the Authority has developed
a managed care system that is responsive to both the
member/subscriber and the provider. It has demonstrated that
a capitated system of payment can be financially viable to
PCPs; administrative and medical costs can be managed
effectively without denying patients necessary medical
attention and care; and a local, responsive and publicly
managed plan can ensure widespread participation of
providers and ensure access to quality care.
The Santa Barbara Regional Health Authority refines and
revises its policies and procedures to ensure that the
program remains effective and efficient in the constantly
changing health care environment. It gladly shares the
lessons it has learned with those charting a similar course
in the management of health care, and looks to continue its
tradition of innovation for years to come.
Top
|
|